Our 92nd Season - 2019



A play by rick elise

music by wayne barker

based on the novel by dave barry and ridley pearson

DIRECTION BY brian feehan



Produced by lauren conlin, alex mogil and tom schrank


Tony-winning Peter and the Starcatcher upends the century-old story of how a miserable orphan comes to be The Boy Who Would Not Grow Up (a.k.a. Peter Pan). A wildly theatrical adaptation of Dave Barry and Ridley Pearson’s best-selling novels. From marauding pirates and jungle tyrants to unwilling comrades and unlikely heroes, Peter and the Starcatcher playfully explores the depths of greed and despair... and the bonds of friendship, duty and love.

The show will be performed at The Hudson Guild Theatre, 441 W. 26th st. New York, NY 10001.

Auditions: We are seeking a cast of up to 12 actors; all roles are open. Performers of all ethnic and racial backgrounds are encouraged to audition. CHARACTER BREAKDOWN.

Where: St Bartholomew’s Church on 50th Street and Park Avenue. Please enter through the Community House at 109 East 50th Street.

When: Monday, February 25th at 7pm (for Members); 7:30pm (for Non-Members*) and Tuesday, February 26th  at 7pm (for Members); 7:30pm (for Non-Members*). *all are welcome, no appointment necessary

Callbacks:  Thursday, February 28th at 7pm.

What to Bring/Prepare: A recent headshot (if you don’t have one, a photo will be taken of you), a resume and your calendar with conflicts. Please prepare one of the audition sides, as well as 32 bars of music in the style of the show OR if a song is not available to you, sing a simple song such as ‘Twinkle Twinkle Little Star’ (accompanist will be provided).

CALLBACK INFORMATION (click each page number for pages; sides will also be available at callbacks):

p. 38: Peter Monologue

Scene 9, p. 24-25 and p. 54-55: Peter and Molly

Scene 2, p. 10: Mrs. Bumbrake, Alf and Molly

Scene 5, p. 16, 17, 18: Aster, Smee, Stache

p. 47: Stache and Smee

p. 12: Ted, Prentiss, Boy, Alf

p. 43-44: Ted, Peter, Prentiss

p. 35: Mermaid song (misc. characters) – done in style of character. i.e. Prawn with an Italian accent.

Performance Dates:

Tuesday, April 30th- 7:30pm

Wednesday, May 1st- 7:30pm*

Thursday, May 2nd- 7:30pm

Friday, May 3rd- 7:30pm

Saturday, May 4th- 2pm and 7:30pm

Sunday, May 5th- 2pm

Ticket Prices:

*$20 Ticket Special Wednesday May 1st only

$30; students and seniors: $27; $45 Premium STARSeats (includes premium seating plus one beverage and concessions snack)

For group rates, please call the box office at 212-378-0248.


Our 91st Season - 2018



Music and Lyrics by Stephen Schwartz

Book by John- Michael Tebelak




Produced by Michael D. Deshields and merrill vaughn

GodpellLogoVers6 (1).jpg

Godspell was the first major musical theatre offering from three-time Grammy and Academy Award winner, Stephen Schwartz (Wicked, Pippin, Children of Eden), and it took the world by storm. Led by the international hit, "Day by Day," Godspell features a parade of beloved songs adapted from the Gospel of Matthew.

The show will be performed at St. Bartholomew's Church- 325 Park Avenue, New York NY 10022.


Tom Schrank as Jesus

Bosa Mora as John the Baptist/Judas

Rachel Acevedo

Sarah Butler

Erika Ji

Alex Mogil

Natalie Pernick

Michael Trainer

Ben Watts

Elisabeth Zimmerman

Performance Dates:

Thursday, November 8th at 8:00pm

Friday, November 9th at 8:00pm

Saturday, November 10th at 2pm and 8:00pm

Sunday, November 11th at 2pm

Wednesday, November 14th at 8:00pm

Thursday, November 15th at 8:00pm

Friday, November 16th at 8:00pm

Saturday, November 17th at 2pm and 8:00pm

Ticket Prices:

$30; students and seniors: $27

$50- the 'All Good Gifts' ticket package; includes premium seating, a beverage and snack from our concessions stand

For group rates, please call the box office at 212-378-0248. More ticket information and packages coming soon!




YCTIWY Logo Draft 3.jpg

You Can't Take It With You

By moss hart and george s. kaufman

directed by joseph hayward

stage managed by page tazewell

Produced by Katelyn Diekhaus and Dilara Eynula


Sweet-natured Alice Sycamore falls for banker's son Tony Kirby. When she invites her snooty prospective in-laws to dinner to give their blessing to the marriage, Alice's peculiar extended family -- including philosophical grandfather Martin Vanderhof, fledgling ballerina sister Essie and fireworks enthusiast father, Paul, might be too eccentric for the staid Kirby's.

The show will be performed at The Hudson Guild Theatre - 441 W 26th St, New York, NY 10001.

CAST (In random order):

Penny Sycamore...Melissa Broder

Paul Sycamore...Ken Altman

Martin 'Grandpa' Vanderhof...Jim Mulllins

Alice Sycamore...Lindsey Zelli

Tony Kirby...Matt Pastorius

Anthony W. Kirby...Tim Burroughs

Miriam Kirby...Katherine Weall

Essie Carmichael...Savannah Lloyd

Ed Carmichael...Alex Mogil

Boris Kohlenkov...Joe Gambio

Mr. DePinna...Dan Grinko

Grand Duchess Olga Katrina...Barbara Blomberg

Donald...Donovan Price

Rheba...Quincie Lewis

Gay Wellington...Tracy Altman


Performance Dates:

Wednesday, April 18th at 7:30pm

Thursday, April 19th at 7:30pm

Friday, April 20th at 7:30pm

Saturday, April 21st at 2pm and 7:30pm

Sunday, April 22nd at 2pm

Ticket Prices:

$30; students and seniors: $27

For group rates, please call the box office at 212-378-0248. More ticket information and packages coming soon!

Clue Logo.jpg


Whodunit? Was it the St. Bart’s Players with a Staged Reading on the 3rd Floor? The St. Bart’s Players will be presenting An Evening Inspired by Clue!, an immersive staged reading of the cult classic movie based on the popular board game of the same name. Join us for a bit of fun and suspense as audience members are taken into the Hill House Mansion for everyone's favorite murder mystery. By the end of the evening, six murders will take place around the audience, and the suspects will be apprehended and escorted out accordingly. 

The reading will be presented in Room 33 of the St. Bart's Community House at 109 E. 50th Street, beginning at 8pm on Thursday, May 10th and Friday, May 11th. A suggested donation of $5 will be collected at the door for all audience members and there will be a cash bar and concession stand. Seating is general admission, on a first-come first-serve basis, with no advanced sales. All proceeds will support the St. Bart's Players. 



A musical cabaret celebrating love in all its forms

produced by michael d. deshields

accompaniment by adam bokunewicz


Choose Love Logo_v3 (1).jpg

June 14 & 15th @ The Community House (109 E. 50th st.) at 7:30pm

$10 Suggested Donation at the Door

Concessions will be available

If you are in love, out of love, searching for love or disappointed by love, you will enjoy this cabaret showcasing songs about love and all its ups and downs, and everything in between. This show will feature solos and duets that illustrate the many kinds of love—not only romantic love but also love for friends and family, as well as love that is unattainable, unrequited or lost.


Our 90th Season - 2017

ALNM - Revised Draft 3 - Right Moon.jpg

A Little Night Music

Music and lyrics by Stephen Sondheim
book by Hugh Wheeler

DIRECTED and choreographed BY alex perez


PRODUCED BY TOM SCHRANK and Alyssa somers farlow

Based on Ingmar Bergman’s beloved film Smiles of a Summer Night, the original production of this musical won six Tony Awards, including Best Musical, Best Book and Best Score.

The show will be performed at The Hudson Guild Theatre - 441 W 26th St, New York, NY 10001.


Madame Armfeldt - Melissa Broder
Desiree Armfeldt - Merrill Vaughn
Frederika Armfeldt - Heather Burgess
Countess Charlotte - Claire Hayner
Anne Egerman-Taylor Vickers
Henrik Egerman- Michael Trainer
Fredrik Egerman- Michael D. DeShields
Count Carl-Magnus- James Neufeld
Petra- Lauren Shakra
Mr. Erlanson/Frid/Page- Kiyan Nourain
Mr. Lindquist/Bertland- Colton Beach
Mrs. Segstrom/Lady- Elisabeth Zimmerman
Mrs. Anderson/Lady- Savannah Lloyd
Mrs. Nordstrom/Mala/Osa- Sarah Catherine Hook

Performance Dates:

Thursday, October 19th at 7:30pm                                                                                                                                             Friday, October 20th at 7:30pm
Saturday, October 21st at 2pm & 7:30pm
Sunday, October 22nd at 2pm
Wednesday, October 25th at 7:30pm*
Thursday, October 26th at 7:30pm
Friday, October 27th at 7:30pm
Saturday, October 28th at 2pm & 7:30pm                                                                                                                                 Sunday, October 29th at 2pm

Ticket Prices:

$30; students and seniors: $27                                                                                                                                                    *All tickets are $25 for the Wednesday, October 25th performance.
**$50 "A Weekend in the Country" package, including premium seating and one complimentary drink & a concessions snack.
For group rates, please call the box office at 212-378-0248.

The Laramie Project     A 3rd Floor Production at the St.Bart's COmmunity House: AugusT 16th, 17th and 18th at 7:30pm   CO-DIRECTED and cO-produced by Michael Deshields and Lynne Marie Mattos    Written by Moises Kaufman   $10 Accepted Donations at the door

The Laramie Project

A 3rd Floor Production at the St.Bart's COmmunity House: AugusT 16th, 17th and 18th at 7:30pm

CO-DIRECTED and cO-produced by Michael Deshields and Lynne Marie Mattos

Written by Moises Kaufman

$10 Accepted Donations at the door

One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest

By Dale Wasserman
Based on the novel by Ken Kesey
Directed by Brian Feehan

The 2001 Tony Award Winner for ‘Best Revival of a Play,’ One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest follows criminal Randle McMurphy, who has gotten himself into trouble once again and been sentenced to hard labor in prison by the court. To escape labor duties, McMurphy pleads insanity and is sent to a ward for the mentally unstable. Once there, he endures and stands witness to the abuse and degradation committed by the oppressive Nurse Ratched against the inmates. Based on Ken Kesey’s 1962 novel, this is a powerhouse play you won't want to miss.

Performance Dates:
*Wednesday, May 17th at 7:30pm
Thursday, May 18th at 7:30pm
Friday, May 19th at 7:30pm
Saturday, May 20th at 2pm and 7:30pm
Sunday, May 21st at 2pm
*90th Season Opening Night Party!

Ticket Prices: $30; $27 for Students and Seniors
For group rates, please call our box office: 212-378-0248

(Presented by special arrangement with SAMUEL FRENCH, INC. )

The St. Bart's Players 90th Season Gala

A celebratory night of theatre and community